James Reilly (Dublin North, Fine Gael)

There is an issue regarding the independence of the doctor the Minister appointed to read mammograms. Dr. Ann O'Doherty is a person of impeccable clinical ability and is held in high regard. I have no difficulty with that whatsoever. However, the Taoiseach told this House that she would review everything, that staff, equipment and quality assurance issues would form part of her report. How could Dr. O'Doherty report on staff when she was a member of the interview board that appointed the member of staff whose work was in question? My understanding is that Dr. O'Doherty may have expressed concerns about this person's suitability, given her lack of experience in mammography. If Dr. O'Doherty exonerates her, people will point to the fact that it was Dr. O'Doherty who appointed her. If she finds against this person, the latter could say that Dr. O'Doherty was biased against her from the beginning. The Minister has placed Dr. O'Doherty in an invidious position.

See this speech in context