Michael McDowell (Dublin South East, Progressive Democrats)

A range of opinions were expressed about the Bill's proposals on the right to silence. Deputy Ó Snodaigh was critical while Deputy Jim O'Keeffe believed I was being too cautious. Perhaps I can take some consolation from being in the middle of this divergence of opinion and suggest that we may have achieved the right balance on this sensitive issue. As is clear to Deputies, the interim report of the balancing of the criminal law group did not go as far as I have, I have not gone as far as Deputy Jim O'Keeffe wants me to and Deputy Ó Snodaigh believes I have gone too far.

Deputy Howlin believed the proposals in section 24 for mandatory sentencing where the first and second offences were ones that appear on the Second Schedule to the Bill had merit. He also described the new crime prevention orders as extremely valuable. Deputy Jim O'Keeffe also believed they were worthwhile, an opinion with which I agree.

Several Deputies spoke about the importance of resourcing the Garda Síochána and were correct when they emphasised the importance of a well managed, well run Garda force with the resources necessary to do the job. I agree with the sentiment expressed that there is no substitute for good police work, but it does not just happen, it needs to be planned and paid for.

The Government has an exemplary record in supporting the Garda. It has initiated a far-reaching reform programme and has matched that with funding, increased personnel and increased and better equipment. The Garda budget for 2007 stands at €1.4 billion, an increase of 11% over last year's Estimate. Garda numbers are at their highest ever. As of 14 March, there were 13,178 fully qualified members compared with 10,702 on 30 June 1997 and more than 14,000 recruited members. The Government has given approval for the Garda force to reach 15,000 members, but we must go further.

These few facts speak for themselves. We are committed to the Garda and our task, to which I have given priority, is to ensure the resources are used to maximum advantage. Additional resources in and of themselves are not sufficient as new and better management and improved accountability are also required. The programme of change I have initiated will help bring that about.

See this speech in context