Gerard Murphy (Cork North West, Fine Gael)

I have certain sympathy for the sentiments behind amendment No. 24. However, I accept the Minister's statement that it may be difficult to get suitable people to take the job if competition is involved. Under the US system, the Administration makes an appointment and the person then appears before a committee of the House. Such a system whereby the person would come before the appropriate committee of this House would be a compromise. It would clearly acknowledge the democratic role of the Oireachtas but would not create the competitive situation about which the Minister is justifiably concerned.

See this speech in context