Mary Harney (Dublin Mid West, Progressive Democrats)

The Irish Kidney Association expressed a view about the RIBA test. Discussions took place between officials and the groups. I also stated that if any new test arises, it can be taken on board also. We wish to ensure we are not leaving out any possible test.

I do not understand the point Deputy McManus made about my changing my mind in regard to minors. We were talking about the loss of consortium, the loss of something one has had. There is no doubt that if somebody is seeking compensation, all of these things are taken into account. Although it is moving away from the issue at hand, if somebody forms a relationship post-diagnosis, while he or she is not entitled to loss of consortium, because one cannot lose something one did not have, he or she is entitled to compensation for mental distress, loss of society, any out of pocket expenses, time taken off work and so on. That is reasonable and right. Contrary to what Deputy Twomey suggested, the Bill is not taking anything away from anyone who has it.

See this speech in context