Denis Naughten (Longford-Roscommon, Fine Gael)

Based on the current proposals, 70% of the income of beet growers will have disappeared by 2008. Does the Minister see a future for sugar production in Ireland? What steps can be taken to ensure that the sugar production industry has a viable future? At least 10% of the funds allocated under the proposed compensation package will be given to sugar beet growers and machinery contractors, but I understand that the Minister rejected a proposal to increase the relevant percentage to 25%. Why did she reject the proposal to assign 25% of moneys to such people?

I would like to ask about the restructuring budget of €145 million. We accept that those funds will not be used to restructure Greencore but to close the remaining sugar plant. Sugar beet growers have invested in quota, land and machinery, but it seems that 90% of the funds which will be made available will be focused on Greencore rather than on the growers. I understand that member states have the flexibility to top up that level of payment. Does the Minister plan to consider such an approach?

See this speech in context