Eamon Ryan (Dublin South, Green Party)

I wish to add to what has been said by Deputies Shortall, Olivia Mitchell and Crowe. While I was briefed by the Minister's Department in terms of an indication of some of the changes proposed, I was unable to table amendments to the Bill in regard to the issue about which I was particularly concerned because I did not have a copy of what the Minister was proposing. It was difficult for me to amend Report Stage amendments that were only being tabled. All I knew about them was the intent of what was proposed.

I do not believe the issue at stake or to be discussed is contentious politically. It is not an ideological divide that will frame a debate on the Bill. It is more important to err on the side of caution when dealing with a rail safety Bill and to ensure that it is dealt with in a manner that allows time for consideration. As an Opposition Deputy, I could not amend an amendment being framed at the time I was considering the wording of my amendment. I found that an impossible task. I ask that the Minister listen to what people on this side of the House are saying, namely, that we need time to consider his latest amendments. If he allows us that time, such consideration would only improve the Bill. I do not believe this is a particularly contentious Bill. What is at issue is a matter of getting it right but if the Minister proceeds the way he is going, he will not get it right.

See this speech in context