Gerard Murphy (Cork North West, Fine Gael)

The Minister acknowledged in his reply to the Senate that the courts are beginning a process whereby they will take the transcripts of both Houses into consideration in certain circumstances. However, for some reason, we in this House are reluctant even to suggest that they may do so. When Senator Ryan dealt with this issue, he clearly stated that there was no obligation on the Judiciary, but that we should at least acknowledge this process as part of the legislation we are now passing into law. It seems odd that the courts are already setting the precedent, yet we seem to be afraid to include it in a Bill that will act as a guideline for the overall interpretation of legislation.

See this speech in context