Tony Killeen (Clare, Fianna Fail)

It must be borne in mind that in all cases prosecution of a number of offences is sought and it is open to the court to impose the maximum fine on each offence. The practice in recent times is for fines to be imposed on each of the breaches of which a company is found guilty. The maximum penalty of €3 million is not necessarily the highest amount a company may be required to pay in fines in particular circumstances. I like the idea of giving the court discretion. A fine of €3 million on each offence in cases where five or six charges are brought against the largest companies is a considerable deterrent. The figure was arrived at following considerable consideration by Government. It is reasonable and it will send the message that needs to be sent in the legislation.

See this speech in context