John Perry (Sligo-Leitrim, Fine Gael)

Why did the former Minister, Deputy Martin, need briefing on this very important Act given that after 2001 there was no doubt about the legislation despite a certain ambiguity in its interpretation before that date? The former Minister, Deputy Martin, is hiding behind civil servants. He launched the health strategy document which was a ten-year plan. The Tánaiste has now inherited that plan without €2 billion.

The Ombudsman's report of January 2001 clearly indicated difficulties with charges. The Ombudsman paid back €25,000 in 2002 and €20,000 in 2003. That was a clear marker. The former Minister, Deputy Martin, cannot hide behind civil servants.

In regard to the liability, why is the former Minister, Deputy Martin, not taking full responsibility? I looked at this file dating back to 2001. The information was well known in the Department. Why is the former Minister, Deputy Martin, not taking the political responsibility which rests entirely with him?

See this speech in context