Cian O'Callaghan (Dublin Bay North, Social Democrats)

Therefore, it could well be the case that when Mr. Makhlouf was with us in June he had already received a request for that transfer and he had not let us know but we will never know. We will never know the situation on that. He is not going to tell us. He is not going to provide any information on that at all - even about the broad timeframe as to when he received the request for a transfer.