Oireachtas Joint and Select Committees

Wednesday, 8 February 2023

Committee on Budgetary Oversight

Report of the Commission on Taxation and Welfare: Discussion (Resumed)

Mr. Gerard Brady:

Yes. We have a number of changes coming down the line, including auto-enrolment pensions. Statutory sick pay has been brought in and consultation is under way on linking social welfare payments to pay. We are moving forward in many different areas, including changes in the pension age. Our view is that this change would be better done within one coherent plan rather than doing lots of different things at different times, sometimes without talking to each other across Departments and groups. If there was a coherence to that, we might be able to bring people along and, crucially, help people to plan for bringing these changes in. What we are doing now is jumping a lot of things on people and giving them less than 12 months to get ready. When that is done, particularly from a business perspective but also at household level, if people do not have time to plan, then either no planning is done and we end up with an adverse reaction when these changes come into place or we have such a short time to plan that we end up with unintended consequences in terms of the legislation not working the first time we do something. We then have to go back again and again. We have seen this happen particularly on the SME tax side. A change is made or announced in the budget, put out in the Finance Bill and then there is uproar when it is finally introduced because it does not work. If instead we had earlier engagement and we brought people into the process earlier, we would have ended up with a better outcome.

Comments

No comments

Log in or join to post a public comment.