Matt Carthy (Cavan-Monaghan, Sinn Fein) | Oireachtas source

It is interesting that in his previous response the Minister referred to the CCPC. There are numerous instances of public bodies that, in practice, do not do what was intended when they were established by the Legislature. In some instances we must be specific in telling a new body we are establishing what we expect of it. In the long term, we must ensure that farmers are getting a fair price for their product. That is the reason people have sought a regulator for so long, and that is the purpose of it. It is because we believe that if a regulator is operating effectively that it will make a big difference in terms of the chain of supply in the market and the position of farmers therein. In order to do that, there must be a basis in terms of farmers and primary producers understanding what the cost of production is and getting paid above that. That cannot be done unless somebody analyses the cost of production. Therefore, in my view, this amendment is crucial. I will press it.

If the Minister is saying there is a different formula of words that will allow him to accept our premise, we will be eager to have unanimity on it and have it endorsed. If, however, he is saying he does not accept the premise that the new body should have the responsibility proposed, I will need to press the amendment.