Matt Carthy (Cavan-Monaghan, Sinn Fein) | Oireachtas source

I have a separate issue that relates to the updates provided on page 4 on major projects at pre-appraisal activity stage. Among the projects for which an update is given is the N2 Clontibret to the Border scheme. As we discussed in the hearing with TII, it has been removed from the funding allocation this year. The price range is now given at €280 million to €340 million, which is fairly broad. I have raised previously that these ranges are very broad. My big question relates to the project status, which indicates the next steps for this scheme are under consideration. Under "comments" it states very bluntly that the scheme is on hold. With regard to the official parlance it would be useful if we were to get clarification as to what, if any, distinction there is between the two comments. A document I received through freedom of information indicated this element of the road was suspended because of funding constraints and a focus on bypass and compact growth schemes. It would be useful to ask TII to provide us with details of the cost-benefit analysis carried out on various projects. Even within the funding constraints we could have issues pertaining to the level of funding allocated. Even within these there are too many questions as to why some projects are favoured above others. I have seen no rationale as to why this project would be demoted and put on hold as against others, other than political considerations, which TII told us when it came before us form a big part of the decisions it makes. It would be useful if the committee could seek details of the cost-benefit analysis carried out on these projects when deciding whether to withdraw funding from one or another.