Simon Harris (Wicklow, Fine Gael) | Oireachtas source

It is entirely the Deputy's call but I would suggest that this proposal merits reflection on his part in light of the changes we made earlier to the Bill. We now have significantly improved reference to the Irish language and its promotion in the objects and functions of the HEA. This section needs to be read in conjunction with the provisions that already are in the legislation in terms of what must be contained in the annual plan, including the requirement to outline the proposed activity and specify the proposed allocation, the monitoring arrangements and how an túdarás shall have regard to its objects. Those requirements now include the Irish language. In fairness, when these amendments were being drafted, that was not covered. The changes we have made mean the Bill now contains a number of additional requirements as to what must be contained in the annual plan. There are four specific requirements and the annual plan shall now capture the changes we have made in regard to the Irish language. It is my view that the issue is now adequately addressed.

In regard to amendment No. 53, which proposes to insert a reference to the Minister for Tourism, Culture, Arts, Gaeltacht, Sport and Media, my view is that there are several places in which reference is made to consulting with other Ministers, as appropriate. That captures the Deputy's requirement and ensures there is consistency across the legislation. There will be occasions, under this Bill, on which the Minister of the day will be required to consult with other Ministers. It might be the Minister for Tourism, Culture, Arts, Gaeltacht, Sport and Media in regard to the Irish language and, on another occasion, it might be a different Minister and in respect of a different matter. The standard provision across legislation has generally been that requirements in this regard are captured by reference to consultation with other Ministers of the Government, where such is necessary or required. It is a cleaner way of legislating to keep that standard provision throughout the Bill.