Oireachtas Joint and Select Committees

Thursday, 11 November 2021

Joint Oireachtas Committee on Health

Delays in Accessing Scoliosis Treatment and Surgery: Discussion

Professor Damian McCormack:

Yes. It is an American implant. The problem with surgical implants in this country is they are not regulated. Medical regulation is very strict in this country and the people doing it do a superb job. Surgical regulation is based on market activity. In other words, individual regulators look at how well something is selling; if it is selling well, it is a "good" implant, which is ridiculous.

That particular implant was tested and invented by a surgeon. The surgeon sent it to his friend in Hong Kong and it was tested on two patients. That was absolutely not sufficient to get Food and Drug Administration approval in the United States, where it was made, but the Americans were quite happy to let it be used in Europe. Having been tested on two patients, a paper was written to say it was great, and that was ridiculous. It got European CE approval and it was used in Europe. With marketing, it became-----

Comments

No comments

Log in or join to post a public comment.