Ms Derville Rowland:

We have to look at this in detail. We are not concerned with a single point in time but with fairness over time. We accept that, over time, one might get the benefit of a discount and we would expect to see fairness over time. I have read the dossier the Deputy has submitted and some of the different examples I have heard raise different questions for us. We have to get into the detail of that and look at those examples precisely. We have to check the conditions and parameters, the cost base and the channels to see what is going on. We have to look at the disclosures and the various issues. I cannot give the Deputy a top-of-the-head answer without looking at the detail. The important point is that-----