Dr. Gabriel Scally:

We are quite convinced of that because when we learned of this, we kept it to ourselves and first discussed it face to face with HSE staff. It was clear from their reaction that this came as a complete shock to them. It is extraordinarily disappointing on several grounds. However, I cannot stress enough that we will pursue the issue with the same rigour as we have displayed in the report and will provide members with as much information as we can obtain. I assure the Deputy of that.

The Deputy stated that she was slightly sorry that legislation for open disclosure will be required. I do not think she should be at all sorry. There is nothing wrong with legislating that patients should be told the truth. It is unfortunate that it has come to this-----