John Dolan (Independent) | Oireachtas source

I thank the witnesses for appearing and presenting their views. I start from a view that we need to trust women and have confidence in their decision making. At the same time, being pregnant, regardless of whether it is desired, is a life-changing moment. We need to keep in mind, therefore, that these decisions are not simple.

On conscientious commitment vis-à-visconscientious objection, Dr. Favier will understand that there has been a major focus on the latter. That is to be absolutely respected. However, this is the first time that I have heard someone speak about conscientious commitment, which is the other side of the coin. I have not heard the issue of conscientious commitment being given parity of esteem in the public arena. That is something that should be considered. We are now seeking to provide a mandated public service and the people who feel a sense of duty to provide that service need to have support. I ask Dr. Favier or the other witnesses to comment on that.

The first workstream in Dr. Boylan's presentation, on early pregnancy, cites evidence from Scotland and states: "We believe that Irish figures should be in line with those of Scotland." That is a statement of belief. Does Dr. Boylan have evidence for this statement or is it based solely on Ireland and Scotland having similar size populations?

On foetal medicine, I was worried when Dr. Boylan said there was only one available MRI in a maternity hospital given that there are 19 maternity hospitals or units. He subsequently provided some clarity on the matter. Will this issue be addressed by the measures to which he referred when responding to Deputy Donnelly?