Pádraig Mac Lochlainn (Sinn Fein) | Oireachtas source

I found the presentation very alarming. I refer to the stated objective of the scheme and that of the Irish Cattle Breeding Federation and the aims are outlined on its website. The presentation and experiences outlined by Mr. McKiernan suggests that the complete reverse is happening, which is absolutely extraordinary. I am alarmed that we have reached a situation where an organisation, like the ICCS, must attend a meeting of an Oireachtas committee in order to resolve an issue. What attempts has the ICCS made to meet the ICBF in order to outline its concerns and experiences? I assume that the claims made by Mr. McKiernan are evidence-based. What efforts have been made? What has been the response? Has the Department of Agriculture, Food and the Marine engaged with the ICCS on these issues? I reiterate that I found the presentation deeply alarming and appreciate that the ICBF will have an opportunity to respond here later this evening.

The format of the ICBF board has been mentioned. Who designed the board? Who put it together? Mr. McKiernan believes the ICBF does not represent the industry. Who made the decision to employ the current structure? One of the key things in any structure, particularly with the stated objectives of the ICBF, is to be representative. One wants a board to be representative and to listen. It is very important to listen to people's real experiences and to respond.

The witnesses gave the example of the deterioration in the sire. How can that happen with a three time all-Ireland champion? I know that is the question the witnesses are putting to us. How in the name of God can that calibre be devalued in that way? I would like a more in-depth understanding of that. I acknowledge that the witnesses have given a number of examples.