Ms Josephine Feehily:

We had two responses. First, we sought to ensure that we could have it on the record so we could use it, and we clarified that with the Commissioner, and, second, we went through the concerns and, as I said earlier, we were already aware, because we had rejected the material, that it was inaccurate and incomplete. We were aware that it was not a report. It did not have a start and an end, it had no methodology or detail and it did not set out the work the analysis service had done, and we had rejected it. Following on from my point that there was nothing of substance that was new, we knew that the material we received was inadequate, incomplete and inaccurate.