Charles Flanagan (Laois, Fine Gael) | Oireachtas source

It is important that we consider the practical outturn of this amendment. It may well be the case that, after three years, we have people who have contributed substantially to the effective working of the commission. They would be regarded as good people and have expertise. They would have acquired three years of experience. It is not unreasonable that they might be asked to serve for a further term of three years.

Deputy O'Callaghan referred to situations in which there might be a level of unsuitability. It is important that such circumstances be considered, but I point to section 23(2), which provides the power to remove a member of the commission from office.

Consider the contribution of lay people across the public service. It is important that, if people are good, competent and doing well and if they wish and are able to serve, the option is there. This provision is no more than that. From that perspective, it is difficult to accept the amendment.