Ms Oonagh McPhillips:

It is hard for me to get into the thoughts that were in the officials' minds at the time. I agree that there appears to be a contradiction in that regard. I will try to help the Deputy by seeking to get into the officials' minds for a second. My impression is that the conversation centred on a row that had happened, or a dispute between counsel, to put it in its mildest terms. I suppose there would have been a possibility that it might have been become public, despite the private nature of the proceedings. There was a sense that the Minister should become aware of it in case it became public and that she was unaware of it. That is speculation on my part, but I am saying it to be helpful.