James Reilly (Fine Gael) | Oireachtas source

This committee has always sought both sides of every story. To echo Mr. Boyle's own words, I am disappointed by his comments, while he might have his own disappointments. I do not think his language furthers his cause.

I want to deal with the issue because it is hugely important to us as a nation. Allegations have been made of extensive mistreatment and abuse of people within an industry. As somebody who lives in north County Dublin, I am very proud of the ports along our coastline, our fishing industry and the men and women who are involved in fishing. I am proud of the manner in which they do their work. As others have pointed out, they seek to feed our people. They are challenged not just by the market, but also by the weather, like many farmers. The huge difference between them and farmers is that their lives are challenged and their safety is at risk. All too often, sadly, we lose valued and loved members of our community. All here would hope to be able to support those involved in the industry in making it as safe as possible. I was talking to some of the organisation members today about the moves that have taken place in that regard such as, at a bare minimum, wearing a life jacket at all times.

I want to comment on the issues raised by a number of people around the scheme itself and how it does not apply to vessels under 15 m. As was pointed out, the task force never mentioned boat size when it came into being. I would support that changing and being open to all operators. We have a duty as legislators and as members of this committee in particular, however, to make sure that the scheme is fit for purpose.

I find a lot of the witnesses' evidence very compelling. What I do not find credible is the idea that there are no rogue operators within any industry or profession, including my own. We need to be realistic. I take on board the point that if there is evidence there, it should be made available to the appropriate authorities. Senator Gavan informs me that several cases of illegal trafficking are with the authorities at the moment. Let us be on the one side here, namely, the side of justice and fairness to all parts of the industry. Let us weed out those who are bringing it into disrepute and not have the entire industry tarred with the one brush because of the bad actions of a few.

I thank our guests for coming in. I reiterate that this industry is hugely important to us and will probably grow in importance. I would like to see that. Again, I reiterate the Chair's words. This committee believes in fairness and due process. That is why the witnesses were invited today to give their side of the story and bring balance. I thank them for doing that. In its own time, the committee will consider all the evidence that has been put before it.

I apologise as I have to leave now. I thank Senator Gavan for allowing me to speak first.