Alan Kelly (Tipperary, Labour) | Oireachtas source

Absolutely. That is why he is needed here with the other witnesses. For the record, we have a complete contradiction in evidence between that given on 4 May and that given today. Evidence has been given that there was a 2 July meeting at which this steering group was set up. We also have a letter from 30 June which says that the Commissioner had been informed. Obviously, we will have to tease these things out but that is a direct contradiction in evidence. Mr. Ruane has read out a letter dated 30 June. If that does not raise serious concerns for each and every one of us, and indeed the Oireachtas, nothing else will. I know we have a job to do. I accept what Mr. Ruane is saying in respect of privilege and I know his role. I will only ask him about facts and his opinion, rather than legal advice. Is that okay?