Oireachtas Joint and Select Committees

Tuesday, 8 November 2016

Joint Oireachtas Committee on Jobs, Enterprise and Innovation

Economic Impact of Brexit: Discussion (Resumed)

4:30 pm

Mr. John McGrane:

I thank the members of the committee for inviting me to give evidence on this very important issue. For those who do not know us, the British Irish Chamber of Commerce is the only organisation representing business activities with interests across our two islands. Our raison d’êtreis to champion, protect and grow the trade between the UK and Ireland, which is worth in excess of €60 billion a year and sustains over 400,000 jobs, evenly spread across Britain and Ireland. The UK is Ireland's largest two-way trading partner, supplying 34% of our imports and taking 16% of our exports. The British Irish Chamber of Commerce works on behalf of its members, large and small, North, South, east and west, connecting them to fresh business opportunities between and from these two islands, growing trade, investment and jobs. We want to ensure that this work continues beyond the current political crisis that now faces us.

As the only organisation representing business interests in both Ireland and the UK, we are uniquely placed to see both the opportunities and challenges that Brexit provides, and there are both. Currently we are seeing one of the challenges take shape in the form of the collapse in the value of sterling. Fluctuations in currency are nothing new but the speed with which sterling has declined has caused a significant challenge for our exporters, particularly those in the agrifood sector who already operate with very tight margins. The reality is that governments cannot magic away the serious impact of sterling's weakening on Irish exporters. It is also not realistic to expect that businesses can simply open new markets that are slow, expensive and just plain awkward to trade with, compared with the ease of doing business with our nearest and most similar neighbours. This is why I believe the best response to this challenge is to help our trading businesses to do even more together to offset unit value changes. Most of them have scope to do just that if we can use our support resources to connect them to more partners, as my colleagues in the British Irish Chamber of Commerce are actively doing.

At the same time, the chamber is also working to help Irish businesses to secure a base within their nearest neighbour to protect themselves from any future barriers to trading with the UK. With 53% of the UK's imports already coming from EU member states, there is substantial opportunity for Irish suppliers to replace some of that trade on a tariff-free basis by establishing directly within the UK sooner rather than later. We should not waste a good crisis and there are certainly opportunities from the UK’s decision to leave the EU that Ireland should be availing of. In the short term, we are assisting UK firms to manage their need to secure an in-EU base for the future by establishing relationships or a base for their business activities within Ireland, as the best alternative base among the various bids for their business by competing EU countries. We are also assisting other foreign direct investors to prefer Ireland over alternative locations. We are working to assist Irish universities to benefit by partnering with British and Northern Irish universities to win valuable EU-funded research contracts for the future.

We need to have a well-founded national strategic plan if we are to take best advantage of these opportunities. Brexit clearly hands Ireland a role to be a key base for both global foreign direct investment and UK-based firms and agencies. The Government's decision to campaign for the relocation of the European Medicines Agency and the European Banking Authority is welcomed by the chamber and is something that we have been active in supporting. We are also working with national and local government to ensure fastest delivery of key resources such as housing, offices, international schools and regulator capacity.

There are very real opportunities for Ireland in the likes of the education and research sector. By leaving the EU, the UK will cut itself off from £1 billion per year in EU funding of its universities and research institutions. If we adopt a genuinely strategic planning approach together, Ireland can position itself as a potential base within the EU for those researchers who are facing loss of their lead role on key research programmes or indeed outright exclusion from pan-European research consortia. In order to achieve this we must ensure we reverse the current trend that sees our universities slipping down the global rankings through implementation of the Cassells report without delay. This really is not the time to play party politics with a vital national resource and I urge all sides to grab this opportunity so we can emerge strengthened by opportunity rather than diminished by loss.

To get the best from Brexit, Ireland must look to our visionaries of the past, such as T.K. Whitaker, for inspiration. Just 50 years ago, Ireland faced huge decisions from a much weaker base. Not long independent, impoverished by a trade war with our neighbour and exporting our young alongside our animals, we had missed out on the industrial revolution and we had no natural resources other than our food, our brains and our work rate. The choices made by our predecessors then shaped what we are now as a vibrant, resilient people, an economy and a community that has paid its dues and which now features the best growth rate in the EU.

We should think carefully now about what we would want our successors to say in 50 years about the choices we get to make now. Brexit is a catalyst for a national strategic plan to guide our success and collective well-being for some generations to come. We should work together now and look forward with ambition, optimism and faith in our collective abilities. We should not only address the challenges and opportunities of the immediate aftermath of the UK people's decision to leave the EU but we should also ask why and what has changed to make a strong nation so decide. Armed with that understanding, we can and must work together in our common interest knowing that we may be the first generation to be able to deliver comprehensive local and even universal well-being or the last to be given the chance.

Comments

No comments

Log in or join to post a public comment.