Jan O'Sullivan (Limerick City, Labour) | Oireachtas source

I was going to raise my issues when we reached the section but as they are being raised during our discussion of the amendments I will mention them now. When we were in private session I supported Deputy Coppinger because I also have two amendments that were ruled out of order. My first amendment is on this section. I sought a referendum to keep the water supply and wastewater treatment supply in public ownership. Unfortunately, my amendment was ruled out of order not because it would cost the State but because it was not considered to be relevant to the Bill. The rule is that we must challenge the Bills Officer over its ruling. I challenge the ruling because I believe my amendment is relevant to the Bill and to the views of people on Irish Water generally.

In the context of the period during which water charges are to be suspended, the Minister has left it open-ended as to how long the period could be extended. Does he have a view on how long the period could be extended?

I ask the Minister for clarity on a matter. One might say this matter might not be relevant but I believe it is. Will Ireland be fined by the European Commission for suspending water charges?