Dr. Mary Wingfield:

I return to the issue of anonymity. Our institute's submission clearly states we are of the view that it needs to be addressed as a matter of urgency. However, it has not been discussed at institute level as to whether there should be anonymity. This is a very complex issue. It is safe to say the majority of people who work in the area are of the view that it is important for children to be able to access information on their genetic origins. There are, however, practical implications which are debated internationally. In jurisdictions such as the United Kingdom where children can access information on their genetic origins and obtain the name and address of the person who donated, this causes a difficulty in the supply of eggs and sperm. The majority of people in Ireland have no choice other than to go to countries such as Spain where anonymity is assured and there is a large supply of eggs. I am not stating I agree with this, but, speaking practically, if there is a total ban on anonymity, it will make it very difficult for couples to access services. This is a matter which requires a very wide debate. I would not like it to be hurried and for it to be said we have not discussed it in detail at the institute.