Ms Josephine Feehily:

The cluster of the bottom four bands is consistent with data put in the public domain by the Thornhill report and other commentators, such as the Dublin Accommodation Finder Terminal, DAFT, and so on. There may be some nuancing within the bands. It is important to remember the valuation date was May 2013. We are very clear in the belief that recent colour supplements do not reflect the valuation that is relevant for property tax. If one views the bands as a cluster they are completely consistent with the other data that were published by the experts at the time. There might be nuances in between.