Mr. John Dempsey:

I will give some context first. Irish Water as a utility has come about in a relatively short time. There is still a lot to be done. We need a lot more data. For the Commission for Energy Regulation to accurately and properly assess submissions from Irish Water in regard to reasonable costs it will be seeking information that will help it determine the answer to the question posed by the Chairman. I cannot answer that question now for the Chairman but I can go back to my previous employment-----