Catherine Murphy (Kildare North, Independent) | Oireachtas source

I oppose this section as I did the section on transferring moneys from motor taxation and vehicle duties to the Minister for Finance. When people pay motor tax, they expect it to be used for the LGF, for which it has been ring-fenced for a considerable period, or for the upgrading of roads. The money is clearly being transferred for the purpose of repaying the national debt. Why do we not call things what they are? Ministers keep telling us that direct taxation has not been increased, but this amount might as well be taken from PAYE. There is a dishonesty in calling something motor vehicle (duties and licences), as it gives the impression that the money raised is for roads. People can see the distinction between that and servicing the national debt.

I wish to address the €600 million transfer to Irish Water. For several years, money has been taken from the LGF and replaced by the household charge and property tax. In effect, property tax is being used to effect the transfer to Irish Water for the purpose of introducing a water charge.

This is a dishonest way to proceed and is an undermining of local government. I am opposed to this and propose to call a vote on this section, which in my view is the most offensive section in this Bill.