Oireachtas Joint and Select Committees
Monday, 20 May 2013
Joint Oireachtas Committee on Health and Children
Heads of Protection of Life during Pregnancy Bill 2013: Public Hearings (Resumed)
2:05 pm
Dr. Yolanda Ferguson:
I will start with that point - accuracy of assessment. There is a notion that psychiatrists do not have tools or measures to make assessments. We have clear experience and training in making assessments in all facets of people who present to our services, including suicide risk assessment. We do this every single day. We are highly trained and highly skilled in making these assessments.
Going back to the question of linking mental health issues with abortion, if we look at women who are more likely to seek abortion, it is not terribly surprising that those who have made that difficult decision did so because of a number of factors, including mental health issues. The phrase "refuses all alternatives and suicide is the only option" displays a cynical approach to women, that they are sitting there saying they will not do this, that or the other, that they only want one thing. That is not what we experience when we see women in crisis.
Deputy Mathews asked about women hurt by abortion. Support groups are usually founded by people who are dissatisfied with something. It is unlikely we would find a support group of women who are pleased with their decision.
It is important that conscientious objection be included in the Bill. That is why we suggest a panel. If a woman cannot avail of the normal pathway of care because her psychiatrist is a conscientious objector, that panel should be formed.
No comments