Mr. Cathal Guiomard:

There is a long history of correspondence and legal action. As I have pointed out we won those legal actions with one exception, therefore, the court's scrutiny of our work seems to involve a judgment that we make legally valid decisions. There is also a long history of Ryanair faulting many parties, it is not limited too our organisation in terms of those who are criticised or written to. In the case of the four particular points that Mr. O'Leary raised in spring 2012 at the start of that sequence of correspondence, the Chairman described him as having successfully extracted answers from the organisation, the replies I gave to him were from our annual report of the year in question. No extraction was required. We had already provided information under these headings and are happy to summarise it again for anybody who may write to us seeking it.