Niall Collins (Limerick, Fianna Fail) | Oireachtas source

It will not come as a surprise to the Commissioner that the closure of Garda stations exercises every community around the country. It is not just a rural issue because there has been an impact in Dublin also. I listened carefully to what the Commissioner said - that it was ultimately a decision of the Minister and Government of the day - but that point has been lost in much of the public debate. It is my understanding that the Commissioner prepares a policing plan and presents it to the Minister and the Government. It can be accepted, amended or rejected, which is the right of the Minister and the Government of the day.

What level and detail of consultation takes place in that regard? It is my experience that there is very little consultation with communities regarding the potential closure of Garda stations and those that would be potentially - although I hate to use the word - targeted for closure. Such decisions are of concern to communities. I sit on a joint policing committee, or JPC, in Limerick County Council. As public representatives, however, we do not have any input into Garda station closures. It is of huge concern to me and those whom I represent.

Does the Commissioner appreciate the negative impact of such closures, given the policing effect his force can bring to these communities? The low number of reported crimes registered in particular Garda station areas is often used to substantiate closure decisions. I would turn the argument around, however, and say that the presence of a Garda station acts as a deterrent and that is why there may be a low level of reported crime.