Oireachtas Joint and Select Committees

Tuesday, 5 December 2023

Joint Oireachtas Committee on Assisted Dying

Religious, Faith-Based and other Philosophical Perspectives on Assisted Dying: Discussion

Shaykh Dr. Umar Al-Qadri:

Ladies and gentlemen, distinguished members of the parliamentary Joint Committee on Assisted Dying, esteemed colleagues and honourable guests, a chairde agus assalamu alaikum, it is a profound honour for me to address this esteemed gathering today, offering insights into the Islamic viewpoint on assisted dying.

In the vast tapestry of ethical considerations surrounding end-of-life decisions, the Islamic perspective is woven with threads of sanctity, endurance and conscientious objection. In Islam, the unambiguous prohibition against suicide or assisted dying is unequivocally expressed in the holy Koran, which states, "Do not kill yourselves, for verily God has been to you most merciful" and, "Take not life which God has made sacred." The hadith, words of the prophet Muhammad, peace be upon him, further reinforces this stance, asserting Islam's united opposition to euthanasia, assisted suicide and assisted dying, categorically denouncing these acts as tantamount to murder.

The sanctity of human life is a foundational principle in Islam, echoed in the holy Koran and various hadiths. Our faith emphasises the importance of endurance and patience in the face of hardship, recognising suffering as an opportunity for spiritual growth. It is within this framework that we approach the complex issue of assisted dying. Islam acknowledges the right to conscientious objection, respecting the autonomy of medical professionals and patients in end-of-life decisions. However, our concerns lie in the potential consequences of legalising assisted dying. We fear it may lead individuals to choose death without addressing the underlying causes of their health issues, including mental health. Moreover, there is a concern that vulnerable populations, such as people with disabilities or the elderly, may feel pressurised to opt for assisted death to avoid being perceived as burdensome.

The Islamic perspective also urges consideration of the potential neglect of long-term care and chronic diseases in the elderly if assisted death is legalised. We believe in the importance of a healthcare system that prioritises comprehensive care and addresses the root causes of suffering. In our brief on the Islamic perspective, committee members will find a more detailed exploration of these principles and concerns. It is our sincere hope that this document will serve as a valuable resource for the committee as it navigates the intricate terrain of legislation related to assisted dying.

Islamic rulings allow for the forgoing of medical care under specific circumstances, distinguishing between life support and ancillary interventions. We emphasise the importance of a nuanced approach, granting flexibility to clinicians in assessing treatment futility. Decisions on withholding or withdrawing medical care are guided by conditions justifying these actions, such as terminal or inevitable death.

Regarding pain control in palliative care, Islamic rulings advocate endurance for non-terminal patients experiencing severe pain. However, during the final stage of illness, severe pain becomes an acceptable indication for withholding or discontinuing care. In these instances, the emphasis should be on pain relief medication and methods to ease the patient's suffering.

I extend my gratitude for the opportunity to share the Islamic perspective on assisted dying. I thank committee members for their time and attention, and for their commitment to understanding the nuanced considerations surrounding assisted dying. Shukran and go raibh míle maith agaibh.