Oireachtas Joint and Select Committees
Tuesday, 3 November 2026
Joint Oireachtas Committee on Fisheries and Maritime Affairs
General Scheme of the Maritime Area Planning (Marine Protected Areas) (Amendment) Bill 2026: Discussion
2:00 am
Jennifer Whitmore (Wicklow, Social Democrats)
Link to this: Individually | In context
It is important to note that the information, data and studies show that MPAs work. They work for diversity, they work for ecology and they work for the fishermen in the area, but only if they are done correctly. That is what we need to be striving for. The reality is that the way fishing happens in Ireland at the moment is not working, and it particularly is not working for inshore fishers. Literally every week, they come in and say that this is not working, that they are being disadvantaged and that their children are not going to be able to fish. It is clear that it is not working at the moment, so there has to be a step change. I believe the process of getting MPAs right is that step change, but it is going to have to involve fishermen. In addition, it has to be very localised. The more local it is, the better. Bay by bay - that is how we need to do this.
I also think it needs to be more dynamic. Professor Crowe not only mentioned that do we not have networks, but he was not sure there is enough flexibility in this legislation to allow it to be dynamic enough to deal with the changes we could see. This could be season by season, or in some instances, it could be a particular current that we are trying to protect because of what that current brings with it. Is the legislation dynamic or flexible enough to deal with that?
Mr. Lynch mentioned proprietary interests. I am worried about this. I am afraid that if we start bringing in proprietary interests, what we are essentially doing is privatising the fishery. We have heard concerns about that. In those instances, it tends to be done based on historical fishing effort and capacity. We are essentially going to be excluding anyone fresh from coming in, which is not something we would want to see. Will Mr. Lynch address the risks of having proprietary interests embedded in the legislation and whether that would lead to privatisation of the stocks?