Brendan Ryan (Labour)

I second the amendment. I wish to respond to the Minister's remark. I am not sure if my absence caused him delight or my return caused him even greater delight.

I came back for the purpose of saying that his is one of the most disappointing performances I have seen from a Minister in the 22 years since I was elected to this House. It is particularly disappointing to see a Minister of considerable ability and good humour read Civil Service briefs as though he has not an idea of his own when we all know he does.